| « Creepy | Transformers » |
July 18, 2007
Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer

I was surprised when I heard about this second movie featuring the Fantastic Four was going to be made, because I didn't think the first movie was that much of a hit. In fact, I dollared that one, and remember liking it just enough to give it a passing grade, despite a lot of cheesiness.
This movie, in which the Four are simultaneously dealing with the pressures of a celebrity/action-hero life and the impending end of the world, is a much better production. It rated PG, which means the action isn't very extreme, but the overall mood of the Four's movies isn't quite as serious as other comic adaptations, and so there doesn't seem to be a need for anything too dark or deep. I'm not sure the PG rating would make a difference for kids, since it doesn't seem targeted at them so much. In fact, since the group almost disbands because Sue and Reed want to go live life on a farm and be normal, I'm pretty sure the kids would have no idea of how to identify with those sentiments.
At any rate, the star of the show is, of course, the Silver Surfer. I had a hard time during the previews, because I was wondering why they would name the movie after a villain, but now that I've seen it, everything makes sense. His demeanor, his look, and his "boss" are amazing and make the movie completely worthwhile.
I don't have much else to say, but that I'm surprised it didn't receive more attention. I think some people expect FF to be like all of the other comic book movies, but the fact that it has a lighter tone is what makes it fun to me. I go in knowing that no one's going to be brooding too much, and I'll tell you one thing - no one in this movie went emo on us, and that in itself probably makes this a better movie than Spider-Man 3.
Posted by Jeri
at 07:03:19 pm | movies
8 comments
Doug, please visit: http://anyeventuality.wordpress.com/2007/06/27/third-generation-comic-book-adaptations-1998-2007/
And then revise your statement.
Wow. I just think that's so backwards. But then again, you had a way softer spot for the Brothers Grimm, so my opinion of your opinions is slightly tainted anyway! ;)
That being said...
My problem with FF2 was that every character was either a) an idiot or b) an a-hole in order to further the plot. And the whole story felt forced along by horrible writing.
SPOILERS
The general's "show down" with Mr. F in the forest? Do grown adults really still talk about high school jock crap? So trite. And the general CAME to him for help. They are globally-recognized superheroes at this point. Whatever.
Doom was USELESS. Why did he show up? HOW did he show up? What did he do that in any way at all would garner anyone's trust? He never helped with the solution to capture the Surfer. He just brooded and then ditched to work on his secret project. So totally unbelievable that they would ever trust him again.
Touching Johnny makes you switch powers... unless you all hold hands, then he gets all your powers. WHA? I guess all we need is love...
And the constant gags and slapstick as ways to show their powers was just dorky.
And Jessica Alba looked HORRIBLE throughout the entire movie, especially in her wedding scenes. That alone is a crime. If they really wanted a blone, blue-eyed Sue Storm, they should have cast a blue-eyed blond.
The first FF was stupid but earnest in its fun. This one should have known better.
Haha. Look at Doug all fired up. I didn't say the movie was without flaws, but for some reason, its tone worked for me, and I thought it was less cheesy than the first movie. I do agree with you about the general and about trusting Doom.