« Light and fluffy Alan Moore interviewGettin' the Led out »

07/17/08

Watchmen trailer out

Filed under: Movies and TV, Comics — Kyle Email @ 02:35:15 pm

Here it is (sigh).

The more I see of this film the more disappointed I prepare myself to be. From the looks of this footage, Zack Snyder has turned the most complex and sophisticated superhero story in the history of comic books into a glitzy CGI-fest.

I don't mean any personal disrespect to Snyder. I think he did well with 300, a comic book that is itself all style and little substance. But for a movie to capture the subtlety of Watchmen it must have a director who is willing to resist the temptation for big special effects shots and create a realistic world populated with authentic human beings, and I just don't see that here.

What I do see are lots of special effects and flashy CGI shots.

I understand that this is just a trailer, and it may be playing up the action to get people interested, so I'll reserve final judgment for when the film comes out. I have to say, though, that I'm not expecting much. It may turn out to be a fine summer action blockbuster, but I doubt it will come anywhere near the subtle complexity of the source material.

2 comments

Comment from: brendoman [Visitor] · http://brendoman.com
I think to enjoy any comic book movie you kind of have to let go of the source material. Otherwise you're just going to end up disappointed. It's just the nature of the beast of film. I thought the trailer looked really good.
07/17/08 @ 15:11
Comment from: Kyle [Member] Email · http://www.brendoman.com/kyle
I think you're right if you're talking about a comic book that has been in publication for several decades and has seen multiple reinventions. For movies like Spiderman or Batman, it's important to be faithful to the characters and the general tone of the series, even though the story itself is not taken directly from any specific story arc. But Watchmen is not like those comics. It is a self-contained story that is the singular vision of its creators, Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons. It is a graphic novel in the truest sense of the word, and the movie should be approached just like an adaptation of any novel, with an appreciation of the characters, the story, the tone, and the major themes the author originally envisioned. I think that's what disappoints me the most. Watchmen is not another comic book series--it is a novel. But the movie looks and feels like any other superhero blockbuster.
07/17/08 @ 16:19

Leave a comment


Your email address will not be revealed on this site.

Your URL will be displayed.
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Name, email & website)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will not be revealed.)

You can just use your OpenID to provide your name, e-mail and url.